Posted 16/12/2005 5:44 AM (#816 - in reply to #815) Subject: RE: Version 6.0.3 of the Codec Packs released
Everything is ok with Standard Pack.
Now I can play also Transport files in Windows Media Player, CPU usage is about 50% - quite good in my opinion.
MPC has problems with Transport files, this has probably to do with Win 2003. If i change from VMR9 to VMR7 playback is better, but not perfect like in Windows Media Player.
I had also some small problems with Haali icons after I removed the splitter to install your pack: icons and associations were not kept. But I think I managed to remake them really nice from File Types option in Windows Explorer.
Posted 16/12/2005 11:48 AM (#821 - in reply to #815) Subject: RE: Version 6.0.3 of the Codec Packs released
Over the past few versions I've set .mp4 association to be removed during uninstall because of a huge number of people having it broken by Nero applications and a lot of players. I was originally going to set the package to detect association problems but the sheer number of programs doing it is very large, hence the detection would take me a very long time to code.
I'm brainstorming on the idea of the playback pack with a file association wizard, if I ever actually get it done.
Posted 16/12/2005 3:06 PM (#830 - in reply to #815) Subject: RE: Version 6.0.3 of the Codec Packs released
The file association problem is pretty delicate in my opinion, it can't be done 100% correctly. Then it comes the uninstall associations problem, there is also a big chance here that things won't go as it should. Then people will come and say than that file won't open only with x player...
So: don't try new things if they can't be done nicely.
Posted 16/12/2005 3:19 PM (#831 - in reply to #815) Subject: RE: Version 6.0.3 of the Codec Packs released
It's not actually as hard as people think, but most installers out there simply change the association without backing it up first, when the people uninstall the association becomes invalid, but if the original was backed up first problems would be less likely.
I took the safe option of clearing .mp4 association to resolve the issue in the best manor, although not an ideal one.
Posted 18/12/2005 4:17 PM (#839 - in reply to #815) Subject: RE: Version 6.0.3 of the Codec Packs released
It is something that I've been considering a lot lately, many users of the K-Lite pack choose it because it has an integrated player, but as you already know it does cause problems during uninstalling and also any other player could cause conflicts.
I still think it's a better idea to create a player pack seperately from the codec packs to ensure that there wouldn't be conflicts.
A package with DivX Player for .divx media, MPC for .mp4 etc. and VLC Player for broken or trouble files.
At the same time though I think most users would agree with you more.
I'll see what I can come up with that would please everyone and be conflict free.
Posted 18/12/2005 4:42 PM (#840 - in reply to #815) Subject: RE: Version 6.0.3 of the Codec Packs released
No, I was talking that garbage codecs left after K-Lite uninstall create conflicts.
A player package is not really necessary in my opinion: you can play almost any kind of file with Media Player Classic. And yes, it can preview or play broken files also. I use it for corrupted files files I get from streams and for preview files in eMule. It works reall well.
And one more advantage for MPC (one big one): it's really easy to make a set up, you can save settings in an .ini file and it has only an .exe.